Opinion needed on two cakes

[displayfireworks1]

I have asked for an opinion on these two cakes. These video are from the China version of YouTube. One has more red stars. Tell what you think.
Video1

http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNTI2MTk1MjMy.html
Video2

http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNTI2NTQ0MzYw.html

[pyro man 205]

it is really hard to tell one is closer then the other but #2 seems to more red in my eyes. both links worked fine for me.

[PyroManiacs]

I like the 1st one. Even though the second one has more stars.

I think the first link has better breaks, plus it has glitter with the stars then delayed crackle.

The second link is just red stars to crackle.

[westcoastpyro]

#1 just ok lots of kinda fast would be good a case at a time.
#2 wouldn't load

[tarkus4]

#1 is the better of the two videos but leave out the crackle and substitute a different effect. There are already to many cakes with crackle.

[btyree]

#1 is better in my opinion. it would combined it with a blue Crysthanamum and a silver salute.

[hatsgoods]

i would say video 1

[boilermaker1991]

number 1, it has a stronger crackle effect, which made a great finale for a cake

[Westpapyro]

Hi everybody, I liked the first one better. The second was more of a delayed crackle.
Chuck

[smilli]

i have to go with the first one, crackles are nice but in the second video they make no sense after the loud burst and fine red stars.